Intolerance! A Timeless Epic Exploring Love, War, and Religious Prejudice
1927 marked a pivotal year in cinematic history, witnessing the release of D.W. Griffith’s monumental silent epic “Intolerance.” This sprawling masterpiece, clocking in at over four hours, interweaves four distinct storylines spanning different eras: the Babylonian period under Nebuchadnezzar, the crucifixion of Jesus Christ, the St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre of 1572, and modern-day America during World War I. Though initially met with controversy due to its graphic depictions and potentially inflammatory themes, “Intolerance” has since been recognized as a groundbreaking achievement in filmmaking technique and storytelling audacity.
Weaving Through Time: A Tapestry of Historical Narratives
At the heart of “Intolerance” lies Griffith’s ambition to explore universal themes of love, hate, intolerance, and redemption across time and cultures. Each storyline presents a different facet of human conflict and prejudice:
-
Babylon: The story revolves around the tragic downfall of a Babylonian princess who defies societal norms by falling in love with a commoner. This narrative showcases Griffith’s meticulous attention to detail in recreating ancient Babylon, with elaborate sets, costumes, and battle scenes that still impress today.
-
The Crucifixion: This segment portrays the final days of Jesus Christ, emphasizing his unwavering compassion and forgiveness even in the face of persecution. While adhering closely to biblical accounts, Griffith imbues the scene with a sense of pathos and human vulnerability rarely seen in religious epics of the era.
-
St. Bartholomew’s Day Massacre: This chilling portrayal of the 1572 massacre of French Protestants highlights the brutal consequences of religious intolerance. Griffith employs stark contrasts between light and shadow, creating a haunting visual atmosphere that underscores the horror and injustice of the event.
-
Modern America: The final segment shifts to the United States during World War I, focusing on two families caught in the crossfire of social upheaval and anti-German sentiment. This storyline serves as a commentary on contemporary issues facing America, demonstrating Griffith’s ability to bridge the gap between historical context and modern concerns.
Technical Innovations: Pushing the Boundaries of Silent Cinema
“Intolerance” wasn’t simply a remarkable story; it was a technological marvel for its time. Griffith employed innovative techniques like multi-exposure, superimposition, and dissolves to weave together the different storylines seamlessly. The use of close-ups to emphasize emotions and long shots to showcase epic battles added layers of complexity and visual impact to the narrative.
| Technical Feature | Description | Impact on Filmmaking |
|---|---|---|
| Multi-Exposure | Superimposing multiple images within a single frame. | Created dreamlike sequences, visually linking different storylines. |
| Superimposition | Layering one image over another. | Showcased the interplay of past and present, blurring temporal boundaries. |
| Dissolves | Gradual transitions between shots. | Smoothed the flow of narrative, emphasizing connections between seemingly disparate events. |
The film’s score, composed by Joseph Carl Breil, further enhanced the emotional depth of the story. The use of grand orchestral arrangements and haunting melodies perfectly captured the sweeping scope and raw emotions of the different narratives.
Legacy of Intolerance: A Controversial Classic
Despite its critical acclaim, “Intolerance” faced significant controversy upon its release due to its graphic depiction of violence and the potential for misinterpreting its message on religious intolerance. Critics accused Griffith of anti-Semitism, pointing to the portrayal of the Jewish people in certain scenes.
While Griffith intended the film as a condemnation of all forms of prejudice, his vision wasn’t always perfectly translated onto the screen. The controversy surrounding “Intolerance” highlighted the complexities of portraying sensitive historical events and the potential for misinterpreting artistic intent.
Rediscovering Intolerance: A Timeless Masterpiece
Today, “Intolerance” is recognized as a groundbreaking cinematic achievement that pushed the boundaries of silent filmmaking. While its controversial aspects remain open to debate, the film’s powerful storytelling, stunning visuals, and enduring themes continue to resonate with audiences nearly a century after its release. “Intolerance” serves as a reminder of the power of cinema to explore complex issues, transcend temporal boundaries, and challenge viewers to confront their own biases.